Non-Vibrating Butt Plug Reviews

Non-Vibrating Butt Plug Reviews: Find Your Ideal Fit

If you're looking for an anal toy that provides satisfying fullness without vibrations, you’re in the right place. My non-vibrating butt plug reviews cover a wide range of designs, materials, and sizes to help you find the perfect plug for comfort, pleasure, and long-term wear. Whether you're new to butt plugs or a seasoned anal play enthusiast, choosing the right material and shape is essential for the best experience.

Shop: USA | UK | Europe | Canada | Australia | New Zealand

Why Choose a Non-Vibrating Butt Plug?

Not everyone needs vibrations to enjoy anal pleasure. Many people find the classic butt plug shape alone delivers all the stimulation they need, thanks to its filling sensation and the way it applies gentle, consistent pressure. A static butt plug can be worn discreetly, used for temperature play, or even incorporated into pet play with tail plugs.

Materials Matter: Which Butt Plug Is Right for You?

Choosing the right butt plug material affects comfort, sensation, and ease of cleaning. Here’s a quick guide:

Soft & Flexible: Silicone Butt Plugs

  • Best for beginners due to a softer feel
  • Warms to body temperature quickly
  • Non-porous, body-safe, and easy to clean

Firm & Luxurious: Glass & Metal Butt Plugs

  • Ideal for experienced users who enjoy rigid plugs
  • Can be warmed or cooled for temperature play
  • Non-porous and ultra-smooth for easy insertion

Unique & Artistic: Wood & Stone Butt Plugs

  • Polished for a completely smooth surface
  • Adds a natural, aesthetic appeal to your toy collection
  • Must be properly sealed and body-safe for safe use

Exploring Fun & Kinky Butt Plug Designs

Beyond classic shapes, non-vibrating butt plugs come in a variety of fun designs:

  • Tail Plugs: Perfect for pet play, with fox, bunny, pony, and even pig tails.
  • Jeweled Butt Plugs: A touch of sparkle for aesthetic pleasure.
  • Long-Term Wear Plugs: Slim-necked designs that stay in place comfortably for extended use.

Find Your Perfect Butt Plug with Honest Reviews

My non-vibrating butt plug reviews give you all the details on comfort, size, and material, so you can choose the best one for your needs. Whether you're a beginner or looking to upgrade your collection, these reviews will help you make the right choice.

Disclaimer: this page contains sponsored reviews and affiliate links.

John Thomas Arnie’s Extremity Fisting Dildo Review

9 out of 10
You get some respite at the wrist, but the feeling of fullness is akin to an inflatable plug. When you’re ready to continue, you'll find the overall girth grows again quickly, offering an even greater challenge; but at this point, it’s a slow, restrained stretch with no unexpected surprises and a more uniform expansion.

John Thomas Toys Curly Twirly Dildo Review

8 out of 10
Price:
£199.00
Looking for a dildo you can literally screw? John Thomas Toys, purveyors of all kinds of fantasy and monster cocks, has one that might be suitable in the form of the Curly Twirly.

Sinloli Extra Large Sparkly Purple Anal Dildo Review

8 out of 10
Price:
£45.00
Brand:
Sinloli
Shop:
Amazon
Materials:
Silicone
It's silicone, massive, marbled galaxy pink and purple colour, and has sparkly glitter bits in. That's at least four of my boxes on "ultimate dildo design wishlist" ticked right there. But you're probably expecting more of a review than that, so read on!

John Thomas Toys Thingy Bob Multi Cock Head Dildo Review

7 out of 10
Price:
£119.00
What's the best part of a dick? I think we can all agree it's the head. So what could possibly be more satisfying than a dildo with a big dick head on it? That's not a rhetorical question: a dildo with FOUR nice big dick heads on it would obviously be better.

John Thomas Dino Slug XL Silicone Anal Stretcher Review

9 out of 10
Price:
£239.00
In my search for ever more exotic alien and monster cocks to submit to, this week I've found myself on the prehistoric planet of Arrakis. After slipping on a particularly slimy rock, I found myself face to face with this sizeable slug-like entity. Suffice to say, I had no hesitation in dropping my space trousers and allowing it to explore my hole.

John Thomas XTRO Fusion Colour Dildo Review

9 out of 10
XTRO was trying to communicate his dark hunger for me. A series of guttural clicks were followed by a deep angry growl, as he grew impatient for me to understand, let alone reciprocate his need. I tried to scrabble away, but couldn't help myself glancing back to find that wasn't the only thing that was growing. Luminous green drool dripped down his gaping maw, landing on his now huge cock. I froze, but at least I could be confident he didn't want to devour me for dinner.
John Thomas Sergeant Major Orange Silicone Butt Plug Review

John Thomas Sergeant Major Orange Silicone Butt Plug Review

9 out of 10
The second of two John Thomas Toys butt plugs I'm reviewing this month, the John Thomas Sergeant Major Orange Silicone Butt Plug is a cute, phallic anal toy which is reliable, effective and easy to use. I chose four products from the hugely varied and colourful John Thomas collection to review: Skittle dildo, the Buxom Lady dildo, the Twisted Hog butt plug and this Sergeant Major butt plug.  
John Thomas The Twisted Hog Pink Pig Face Butt Plug Review

John Thomas The Twisted Hog Pink Pig Face Butt Plug Review

9 out of 10
I've been enjoying trying out some of the wondrous John Thomas toys recently, as you'll have seen from my recent Skittle Dildo and Buxom Lady dildo reviews. I also chose two butt plugs from the colourful and diverse range; the Sergeant Major butt plug and the item I'll review in full below: the John Thomas The Twisted Hog Pink Pig Face Butt Plug.
John Thomas The Buxom Lady Neon Green Silicone Dildo Review

John Thomas The Buxom Lady Neon Green Silicone Dildo Review

9 out of 10
I've been interested in trying out some of the JTT range for quite a while, especially as they've had rave reviews from resident reviewer Tigerlily. After much deliberating I chose the Skittle dildo, the Buxom Lady dildo, the Sergeant Major butt plug and the Twisted Hog butt plug. This review is for the John Thomas The Buxom Lady Neon Green Silicone Dildo, and I have the medium size in medium firmness.
John Thomas Skittle Yellow Anal Stretcher Dildo Review

John Thomas Skittle Yellow Anal Stretcher Dildo Review

9 out of 10
I decided to choose some John Thomas dildos and plugs to review for myself, and opted for the Skittle dildo, the Buxom Lady dildo, the Sergeant Major butt plug and the Twisted Hog butt plug. This review is for the John Thomas Skittle Yellow Anal Stretcher Dildo, and I have the small size in medium firmness. 

John Thomas Umbungo’s Finger Anal Probe Review

8 out of 10
Who is Umbungo, and why is his finger so unreasonably long? Your guess is as good as mine. But what I can tell you is that his finger feels utterly lovely going up my bum.

John Thomas Woody Purple Silicone Dildo Review

8 out of 10
The John Thomas Toys Woody is aimed at people who, while watching Lord of the Rings, saw the enormous Ents emerge from the forest, and thought to themselves "I wonder what an Ent's cock looks like? I'd love to fuck one and find out".
John Thomas Toys Depth Training Colon Snake Silicone Dildo Review

John Thomas Toys Depth Training Colon Snake Silicone Dildo Review

8 out of 10
...the Colon Snake is one of the longest on the market. Compared to other anal depth trainers which are of uniform width, the head provides a little extra stimulation on the way out too, without being so big that it might get caught on something. It's a fun little feature, and if your fantasy is a snake up the bum, you're sorted.

Seven Creations Roll Play Medium Butt Plug Review

8 out of 10
The Seven Creations Roll Play Medium Butt Plug (with jiggle ball and suction cup) was ordered from Lovehoney together with three other anal sex toys I thought would be suitably sized for my experience level. They all arrived in the same box within 2 working days of placing the order.

John Thomas Toys Parasite Platinum Silicone Dildo Review

8 out of 10
The Parasite is, without doubt, the oddest looking dildo I've ever seen. And I've seen a lot of fantasy dildos. But it's that uniqueness that draws me to it. It doesn't look even remotely penis-shaped, and I suspect you could hide it in plain sight on a hallway shelf alongside other movie props and quirky memorabilia. It's pretty hideous, actually, but this is exactly why I was delighted at the thought of getting penetrated by it.

Lovehoney Booty Buddy Silicone Butt Plug Review

8 out of 10
Price:
£12.99
The size and resulting light weight of this beginner's product effectively eliminates any noticeable teasing to either the prostate or perineum. It has to be emphasised that the product is designed for beginners however, and as such, for the intended purchaser, the mere wearing of plugs may and should create some excitement.
Sinclair Select Deluxe Silicone Dilators Set Review

Sinclair Select Deluxe Silicone Dilators Set Review

10 out of 10
Price:
£46.00
Shop:
SheVibe
Materials:
Silicone
In my opinion, the Sinclair Select Deluxe Silicone Dilators Set is a fantastic buy for those who struggle with vaginal or anal penetration for whatever reason; vaginismus, a naturally petite vagina, anal play newness or shyness or other.
NS Novelties Silicone Unicorn Tails Butt Plug Review

NS Novelties Silicone Unicorn Tails Butt Plug Review

10 out of 10
As you'll have read in my recent NS Novelties Silicone Colours Pride Edition 5 Inch Dildo review, I was recently asked if I’d like to review some of the raunchy rainbow collection of sex toys and lingerie Lovehoney collated in celebration of Pride Month 2019. The second item I’ve reviewing is this glorious NS Novelties Silicone Unicorn Tails Butt Plug.
Loving Joy Medium Cream Butt Plug Review

Loving Joy Medium Cream Butt Plug Review

7 out of 10
Price:
£8.95
Materials:
Rubber
The description of this butt plug is slightly misleading I think, the Loving Joy Medium Cream Butt Plug seems to me to be anything but 'medium'! When it arrived I ripped open the packaging and gasped at the girth on display, I knew I would need to serious warming up before getting this fella inside!
NS Novelties Oinkz Silicone Pig Tail Butt Plug Review

NS Novelties Oinkz Silicone Pig Tail Butt Plug Review

8 out of 10
Thanks to this month's Pleasure Panel, I got the chance to squeal like a piggy as I tested out the NS Novelties Oinkz Silicone Pig Tail Butt Plug. Are you ready to go the whole hog with this porcine plug?