Butt Plug Reviews

Butt Plug Reviews: Find the Best Anal Toys for You

Whether you're an anal play beginner or an experienced user, finding the right butt plug is essential for pleasure and comfort. In my butt plug reviews, I explore different sizes, shapes, and materials to help you choose the perfect one for your needs.

Shop: USA | UK | Europe | Canada | Australia | New Zealand

From beginner-friendly trainer sets to high-tech vibrating options, I test and review a wide variety of plugs so you can make an informed decision.

Choosing the Right Butt Plug: What to Consider

Not all anal toys are the same. Here’s what to think about before you buy:

  • Size Matters – Anal toys often feel larger than expected. Pay attention to the circumference and not just the length.
  • Material & Safety – Choose body-safe, non-porous materials like silicone or glass for hygiene and durability.
  • Vibrating vs Non-Vibrating – Prefer deep, rumbly vibrations or a simple, solid plug? My reviews cover both styles.
  • Special Features – Remote-controlled, rechargeable, weighted, or even connected to a cock ring—there’s a plug for every preference!

Related: My guide to finding the best anal toy for you

Lube Is Essential for Anal Play

Unlike the vagina, the anus doesn’t produce natural lubrication, so a high-quality anal lubricant is a must. I recommend using long-lasting, thicker lubes to ensure a smooth, comfortable experience. Avoid desensitising gels, as they can mask discomfort and increase the risk of injury.

Find Your Perfect Butt Plug

From small, tapered plugs for beginners to advanced anal toys with intense sensations, I’ve reviewed them all. Read my detailed, honest reviews to discover the best butt plug for your desires. Explore now!

Disclaimer: this page contains sponsored reviews & affiliate links

Juliet Toys Pooch Knot Dildo Review: Fantasy Dog Sex Toy

9 out of 10
Price:
£30.00
Materials:
Silicone
Whether you’ve got a canine kink or you’re just a perverted little pup, you’re going to love the sex toy I’m sharing my thoughts on today. The Juliet Toys Pooch Knot Dildo is a fantasy dog sex toy complete with tell-tale pointed tip, sensuously ridged shaft and a glorious bulging knot, finished with a suction cup base for secure filthy fuckery throughout every rampant ride.

The One Anal Plug Set Review: Affordable Trio of Black Silicone Butt Plugs

10 out of 10
Today I’m sharing my thoughts on The One Anal Plug Set, a simple trio of butt plugs at an affordable price. They are made from silky smooth silicone, presented in universally appealing black colour with a traditional teardrop shape with anal-safe bases. With three different sizes to explore, I approached this set feeling like an all-grown-up Goldilocks – hoping there would be at least one plug that felt just right.

Hankey’s Toys Corn Dildo Review

10 out of 10
Shucks, I guess it’s time for a brand-new & exciting Hankey’s Toys review! This month I’m sharing my thoughts on the ear-isistible Hankey’s Toys Corn Dildo. This sunshine yellow kinky cob popped into my pleasure toy collection and promised to butter me up the right way. Is this delicious-looking dildo totally a-maize-ing, or just a corny novelty? Read on for all the juicy details!

Twisted Beast The Serpent Snake Dildo Review

10 out of 10
Price:
£119.95
Today I have the joy of sharing my thoughts on the Twisted Beast The Serpent Snake Dildo, a sex toy crafted by the kinky team over at the Twisted Beast sex toy store. I had the pleasure of reviewing two other Twisted Beast sex toys here at the Cara Sutra sex blog, so I was very excited to experience this superbly long, flexible sex snake.

Juliet Toys Sweat Blood Dog Dildo Butt Plug Tail Review

8 out of 10
Price:
£48.00
Materials:
Silicone
The shape of the plug, plus that softness, made for a filling, deeply internally stimulating but also comfortably pleasurable experience while wearing it. The soft, fluffy tail helped inspire kink fantasies which lasted me all the way until I eventually indulged in ultimate pleasure, by bringing myself to orgasm with the help of a vaginal dildo and a clitoral vibrator. Greedy puppy? Absolutely.

Juliet Toys Thundr Vibrating Horse Dildo Review

9 out of 10
Price:
£106.00
Materials:
Silicone
Time to start horsing around and introduce the newest stallion in my sex toy stable! Thanks to Juliet Toys, I saddled up for some equine ecstasy with the Juliet Toys Thundr Vibrating Horse Dildo with remote control.

Hankey’s Toys Realistic Banana Dildo Review

9 out of 10
Time to get a little fruity! My first sex toy review of 2025 is for the a-peeling Hankey’s Toys Realistic Banana Dildo. After enjoying this curved sensation all holiday season, I’m ready to reveal all the slippery ins and outs. Read on to find out if this fantastical design from Hankey’s Toys makes for a ripe ‘n rampant addition to your intimate fruit bowl!

Hankey’s Toys Minotaur Dildo Review

10 out of 10
Here is an unapologetically huge sex toy which favours a defiant, snorting & stamped-hoof challenge over coquettish seduction. Would I survive a toy testing tango with this passionate creature unscathed? Bravely, wielding naught but a bottle of lube, I entered the ring…

Nothosaur Toys Rockman Fantasy Dwarf Dildo Review

10 out of 10
It’s quite fun brandishing your weapon of choice, heading out on a board game adventure with friends, finding treasure & trouble in equal measure – think Lord of the Rings setting, with cards, dice, snacks and laughter. So, when the Nothosaur Toys team offered their newest sex toy to review, the Nothosaur Toys Rockman Fantasy Dwarf Dildo, I leapt at the chance.

Hankey’s Toys Seahorse Dildo Review

10 out of 10
Did you know that seahorses are the only fish species that can hold your hand? I certainly needed someone to hold my hand as I tried out this month’s review toy from the kinky collection at Hankey’s Toys. My Hankey’s Toys Seahorse Dildo puts the “AAAAAR!” into ‘Large’...

Nothosaur Toys Alla Tentacle Dildo Review

10 out of 10
A shadow which is suddenly transformed into the crystal-clear dominant force of a predator from the depths, as one long, gleaming tentacle crashes through the surface of the water and captures its prey.
EdenFantasys Black Rose Glass Butt Plug Review

EdenFantasys Black Rose Glass Butt Plug Review

10 out of 10
Price:
£23.00
Materials:
Glass
I love roses, I love black, I love glass sex toys and I love anal sex toys – so what more is there to say? Well, I guess this review should go into a little more detail about the product than that… Read on for my full review of the EdenFantasys Black Rose Glass Butt Plug, which includes a little video for you to enjoy.
EdenFantasys Joy Ride G-Spot Vibrator Review

EdenFantasys Joy Ride G-Spot Vibrator Review

8 out of 10
Price:
£63.00
The EdenFantasys Joy Ride Luxury Silicone G-Spot Vibrator seems like a fairly standard rechargeable vibrator – I was buzzed to discover an orgasmic secret when travelling a different route. More about that in a little while. Let’s have a closer look at this bump ‘n buzztastic vibrator.

Hankey’s Toys Cockadile Dildo Review

10 out of 10
They say you should "never smile at a crocodile”  but I just couldn’t help it when I first set eyes on this reptilian nether-predator. The Hankey’s Toys Cockadile Dildo is another jewel from the Mr Hankey’s sex toys collection, an insertable sex toy designed like the closed jaws and head of a crocodile...

Nothosaur Toys Virgo Dildo Review (The Zodiac Sex Toys Collection)

10 out of 10
I hadn’t heard of Nothosaur Toys before I was approached for this sex toy review, but I’m so glad I know about them now! They create all kinds of fantastical and exotic dildos, based on theology & legends, in a wide variety of colours and textures. Today I’m reviewing the Nothosaur Toys Virgo Dildo, from their Zodiac sex toys collection. Just look at how gorgeous it is!

Hankey’s Toys Hentai Dildo Review: Erotic Octopus Sex Toy

10 out of 10
It’s time for another hot 'n horny Hankey’s Toys review! This month I’m sharing my thoughts on the Hankey’s Toys Hentai Dildo, which I selected in burnt ember colour, in small size, with medium firm silicone and with the optional Vac-U-Hole in the base.

Hankey’s Toys Dog Dildo Review

10 out of 10
The Hankey’s Toys Dog Dildo had me gasping at the size before I had even taken the wrapper off. I’m new to knotted dildos, if not puppy play, so I was excited about the challenge - as well as the erotic experience of trying this pleasure pup out. Would this stray who wants to play have me howling with joy?

Hankey’s Toys Dildos & Dragons Dildo Review

10 out of 10
What a magical tool to have in your world of wankcraft arsenal! This delightfully hefty piece of toybox treasure invites you to journey deep into a new, erotic land and unleash the beast of your fiercest orgasms. Are you ready for this pleasure quest, masturbation adventurers? Introducing the Hankey’s Toys Dildos & Dragons dildo!

Hankey’s Toys Kinky Cobra Dildo Review

10 out of 10
Wait until you see the sinuous creature I’m reviewing this month: the Hankey’s Toys Kinky Cobra Dildo! So many thanks to the Hankey’s Toys team for yet another huge and delicious beast for me to straddle, tame and ride.

Hankey’s Toys Sex Machine Dildo Review

10 out of 10
Have you ever fantasised about having sex with a robot? Android sex fascinates plenty of us. The emotionless functionality. The relentless motion. The efficiency. Well, the sex toy I’m reviewing today will certainly be of interest...