Tail Plug Reviews

Tail Plug Reviews – The Best Kinky Puppy Play & Pony Play Tails

Looking for the best tail plug reviews? You’re in the right place!

I’ve tested and reviewed a variety of tail plugs, from luxurious faux fur designs to sleek silicone fantasy tails. Whether you’re into pet play, roleplay, or just want to add something visually striking to your experience, my in-depth reviews will help you find the perfect tail plug for your desires.

shop now button

About Furry Fetish Tail Plugs

Tail plugs offer a unique combination of anal pleasure and visual appeal, making them a favourite among those who enjoy pet play and fantasy roleplay. Whether you want to embody a playful pup, a majestic pony, or a wild fox, the right tail plug can complete your look while delivering satisfying sensations.

Top Picks: Kinky Tail Plugs

After testing many tail-style anal toys, these three recently reviewed plugs stand out:

1. Lovehoney Fluffy Bunny Tail Butt Plug

A beginner-friendly option with a soft, fluffy bunny tail and a smooth silicone plug for comfortable wear. Perfect for hopping into pet play!

2. MEO Pony Play Metal Tail Plug

This striking ponytail plug features a heavy-duty metal base and a flowing synthetic tail, ideal for equestrian roleplay and dominance games.

3. Ouch! Luxury Faux Fox Tail Plug

A beautifully soft faux fur tail with a tapered silicone plug, giving a realistic fox-like appearance while remaining body-safe and comfortable.

How to Choose the Right Tail Plug

Finding the perfect tail plug means considering several key factors:

  • Material – Choose body-safe silicone, stainless steel, or quality faux fur for comfort and durability.
  • Plug Shape & Size – Beginners should start with smaller, tapered plugs, while experienced users may prefer larger or weightier designs.
  • Tail Length & Style – Short, fluffy tails suit bunny or kitten play, while longer, flowing tails work well for fox and pony themes.
  • Attachment Quality – Ensure the tail is securely fastened to the plug to prevent detachment during play.

Find Your Perfect Tail Plug Today

Explore my latest tail plug reviews and discover the best designs for pet play, fantasy roleplay, and stylish anal fun.

Disclaimer: this page contains sponsored reviews and affiliate links

Juliet Toys Sweat Blood Dog Dildo Butt Plug Tail Review

8 out of 10
Price:
£48.00
Materials:
Silicone
The shape of the plug, plus that softness, made for a filling, deeply internally stimulating but also comfortably pleasurable experience while wearing it. The soft, fluffy tail helped inspire kink fantasies which lasted me all the way until I eventually indulged in ultimate pleasure, by bringing myself to orgasm with the help of a vaginal dildo and a clitoral vibrator. Greedy puppy? Absolutely.
NS Novelties Silicone Unicorn Tails Butt Plug Review

NS Novelties Silicone Unicorn Tails Butt Plug Review

10 out of 10
As you'll have read in my recent NS Novelties Silicone Colours Pride Edition 5 Inch Dildo review, I was recently asked if I’d like to review some of the raunchy rainbow collection of sex toys and lingerie Lovehoney collated in celebration of Pride Month 2019. The second item I’ve reviewing is this glorious NS Novelties Silicone Unicorn Tails Butt Plug.
NS Novelties Oinkz Silicone Pig Tail Butt Plug Review

NS Novelties Oinkz Silicone Pig Tail Butt Plug Review

8 out of 10
Thanks to this month's Pleasure Panel, I got the chance to squeal like a piggy as I tested out the NS Novelties Oinkz Silicone Pig Tail Butt Plug. Are you ready to go the whole hog with this porcine plug?

Loving Joy Furry Fantasy Black Panther Tail Butt Plug Review

8 out of 10
Price:
£34.95
Materials:
Metal
Both my submissive and I love to have a little kitty play, and when I saw the fantastic looking Loving Joy Furry Fantasy Black Panther Tail Butt Plug from Loving Joy, my heart skipped a beat. I knew that we could use it together with our kitty ears and mittens to enjoy some kinky roleplay that would have us both purring in delight.

Tantus Dragon Tail Review (Silicone Dildo, Anal Toy & Whip)

10 out of 10
Price:
£25.00
Brand:
Tantus
Materials:
Silicone
I was very excited to receive the Tantus Dragon Tail (Silicone Dildo, Anal Toy And Whip) from the Pleasure Panel for my open and honest review. I’m a massive Game of Thrones fan so the idea of being able to be bitten by a dragon was very exciting. Tantus advertise this Dragon Tail as the ultimate in bitey.
Loving Joy Furry Fantasy Red and Black Fox Tail Plug Review

Loving Joy Furry Fantasy Red and Black Fox Tail Plug Review

10 out of 10
Price:
£34.99
Materials:
Metal
Once inside, I could hardly wait to see how the bushy tail of the Loving Joy Furry Fantasy Red and Black Fox Tail Plug looked, now it was in the correct place and not simply being twirled in my hands. It’s a beautiful plug – so bushy...

Titus Silicone Series Remote Control Small Puppy Tail Pro Review | Pleasure Panel

9 out of 10
Price:
£59.99
Brand:
Titus
Materials:
Silicone
I was delighted when I saw the Titus Silicone Series Remote Control Small Puppy Tail Pro available for review as part of the Pleasure Panel as I have recently started puppy play with my female submissive. Already having a collar and knee pads, I was keen to add a tail to her outfit.

Titus Silicone Series Medium Puppy Tail Butt Plug Review | Pleasure Panel

9 out of 10
Price:
£39.99
Brand:
Titus
Materials:
Silicone
This month, I got to indulge in a little puppy play, thanks to Clonezone. This is the Titus Silicone Series Medium Puppy Tail Butt Plug, available now for £39.99.

Loving Joy Furry Fantasy Rainbow Tail Butt Plug Review

7 out of 10
Price:
£24.95
Materials:
Metal
Why just wave a flag for Pride Month when I can wiggle my rainbow-tail-plugged bisexual arse instead? This lovely looking butt plug -which is made of metal and has a faux fur rainbow tail- costs just £24.95. It's part of Loving Joy's Furry Fantasy collection, and like many Loving Joy sex toys it's extremely reasonably priced.
Crystal Delights 5 Color Faux Pony Tail Butt Plug Review

Crystal Delights 5 Color Faux Pony Tail Butt Plug Review

10 out of 10
Price:
£90.00
Shop:
SheVibe
Materials:
Glass
Crystal Delights are a well-known US based brand specialising in the most beautiful tail plugs I’ve ever seen. As well as their famous tails Crystal Delights make stunning princess plugs with jewels of all assorted colours. They’re the kind of sex toy you don’t want to hide.

Crystal Delights Pink Faux Bunny Tail Butt Plug Review

9 out of 10
Price:
£65.00
Shop:
SheVibe
Materials:
Glass
So finally, I really enjoyed this Crystal Delights Tail Plug, it was fun to play with and I was pleasantly surprised at how soft the tail itself was considering it's faux fur – you really wouldn’t know!
Crystal Delights Reindeer Tail Butt Plug Review

Crystal Delights Reindeer Tail Butt Plug Review

9 out of 10
Price:
£73.00
Shop:
SheVibe
Materials:
Glass
On the first time we used the Crystal Delights Reindeer Tail Butt Plug, my girlfriend fell in love with it. Not only does the high quality glass feel amazing, but the slightly longer stalk just fits more comfortably in her compared to other plugs that we had used. The bulb pops in nicely, giving a good full feeling.

Crystal Delights Crystal Minx Faux Pony Tail Plug Review

9 out of 10
Price:
£85.00
Shop:
SheVibe
Materials:
Glass
Wearing the Crystal Delights Crystal Minx Faux Pony Tail Plug was a lot of fun. There is something kinky about feeling the tail between your cheeks and having it brush against the back of your legs.
NS Novelties Filly Tails Silicone Pony Tail Butt Plug Review

NS Novelties Filly Tails Silicone Pony Tail Butt Plug Review

8 out of 10
...add the pony tail and suddenly an otherwise blasé butt plug is magically transformed into a toy I simply can not live without! The tail portion of the plug is lovely. My particular NS Novelties Filly Tails Silicone Pony Tail Butt Plug arrived in black but it is also available in chestnut (brown) and palomino (blonde), or if you opt for the Unicorn Tails you can get it in a whole host of bright, fun colors! And not to worry, this tail is completely animal friendly and is made from faux hair. Zero My Little Ponies were harmed in the making of this butt plug.

Loving Joy Furry Fantasy Black Fox Tail Butt Plug Review

9 out of 10
Price:
£32.95
Materials:
Metal
...the August Pleasure Panel goodies were revealed; among them was the gorgeous and distinctive Loving Joy Furry Fantasy Black Fox Tail Butt Plug. Luckily, I was selected to test and review this tail.

Loving Joy Furry Fantasy Bunny Tail Plug Review (Black)

9 out of 10
Price:
£24.95
Materials:
Metal
I was lucky enough to review the White Furry Fantasy Bunny Tail Plug for Sex Toys UK. I absolutely loved it, so when Cara allocated me the larger black version of the same plug I was very excited.

Titus Silicone Series Puppy Tail Butt Plug Large Review | Pleasure Panel

9 out of 10
Price:
£44.99
Brand:
Titus
Materials:
Silicone
This month we are absolutely delighted to receive and review the Titus Silicone Series Puppy Tail Butt Plug Large from Clonezone. Puppy play isn’t something we have done before but hey we're very much a try anything once couple so here goes.

Titus Silicone Series Puppy Tail Butt Plug Medium Review | Pleasure Panel

7 out of 10
Price:
£39.99
Brand:
Titus
Materials:
Silicone
I’m not into puppy play, but I’m always game for a good butt plug. After submitting 3 reviews for the May Pleasure Panel round, Cara had a few more items to review so I decided hey, why not help out, it is my pleasure! So a week later the Titus Silicone Series Puppy Tail Butt Plug Medium arrives in the post.

Titus Silicone Series Puppy Tail Butt Plug Small Review | Pleasure Panel

8 out of 10
Price:
£34.99
Brand:
Titus
Materials:
Silicone
I was pleased to be selected to test and review the Titus Silicone Series Puppy Tail Butt Plug Small, for the Pleasure Panel. I would like to thank Cara for selecting me and Clonezonedirect.co.uk for supplying the toy.

MEO Pig Tail Butt Plug Review

7 out of 10
Price:
£44.00
Brand:
MEO
Shop:
MEO.de
Materials:
PVC
Once we finally got chance to get it open we had a lot of fun. Although the butt plug has a very smooth look it did require plenty of lube (water based lubricant only) as the PVC is quite tacky and would just rub and be painful otherwise. The girth of the MEO Pig Tail Butt Plug is great especially if you haven’t had much practice but would be good if there was options of different sizes as it could be a struggle to keep in place as the neck of the plug is not much narrower than the part inserted.