Tail Plug Reviews

Tail Plug Reviews – The Best Kinky Puppy Play & Pony Play Tails

Looking for the best tail plug reviews? You’re in the right place!

I’ve tested and reviewed a variety of tail plugs, from luxurious faux fur designs to sleek silicone fantasy tails. Whether you’re into pet play, roleplay, or just want to add something visually striking to your experience, my in-depth reviews will help you find the perfect tail plug for your desires.

shop now button

About Furry Fetish Tail Plugs

Tail plugs offer a unique combination of anal pleasure and visual appeal, making them a favourite among those who enjoy pet play and fantasy roleplay. Whether you want to embody a playful pup, a majestic pony, or a wild fox, the right tail plug can complete your look while delivering satisfying sensations.

Top Picks: Kinky Tail Plugs

After testing many tail-style anal toys, these three recently reviewed plugs stand out:

1. Lovehoney Fluffy Bunny Tail Butt Plug

A beginner-friendly option with a soft, fluffy bunny tail and a smooth silicone plug for comfortable wear. Perfect for hopping into pet play!

2. MEO Pony Play Metal Tail Plug

This striking ponytail plug features a heavy-duty metal base and a flowing synthetic tail, ideal for equestrian roleplay and dominance games.

3. Ouch! Luxury Faux Fox Tail Plug

A beautifully soft faux fur tail with a tapered silicone plug, giving a realistic fox-like appearance while remaining body-safe and comfortable.

How to Choose the Right Tail Plug

Finding the perfect tail plug means considering several key factors:

  • Material – Choose body-safe silicone, stainless steel, or quality faux fur for comfort and durability.
  • Plug Shape & Size – Beginners should start with smaller, tapered plugs, while experienced users may prefer larger or weightier designs.
  • Tail Length & Style – Short, fluffy tails suit bunny or kitten play, while longer, flowing tails work well for fox and pony themes.
  • Attachment Quality – Ensure the tail is securely fastened to the plug to prevent detachment during play.

Find Your Perfect Tail Plug Today

Explore my latest tail plug reviews and discover the best designs for pet play, fantasy roleplay, and stylish anal fun.

Disclaimer: this page contains sponsored reviews and affiliate links

MEO Fox Tail Butt Plug Review

8 out of 10
Price:
£45.00
Brand:
MEO
Shop:
MEO.de
Materials:
Metal
It really doesn't take much to get me into kitten play mode and after putting the MEO Fox Tail Butt Plug in I was right in the head space. I proceeded to prance around showing off my new tail to my owner. I was in kitten heaven! It made my owner happy to see his kitten so happy. He could tell I was by the prancing and general body language, not forgetting the happy mews! No matter how much prancing I did, the tail stayed put. In order to test the tail out properly I thought I better also curl up on my owners' lap for pets. My new tail was going down a treat.

Kinky Tails Pink Pony Tail Glass Butt Plug Review

10 out of 10
Price:
£27.99
Brand:
Bondara
Shop:
Bondara
Materials:
Glass
I have a real obsession with My Little Pony so when my other half mentioned buying a pony tail butt plug I was totally excited by the suggestion. I wanted something pretty and girly and My Little Pony-ish but looking around found that lots of the really pretty tail plugs were very pricey and was reluctant to pay out a lot of money for something we had no experience in.

Crystal Massager Foxy Fox Tail Butt Plug Review

9 out of 10
Price:
£15.00
Materials:
Glass
The Crystal Massager Foxy Fox Tail Butt Plug is very pretty. It’s our third tail plug, and whilst not as stunning as our stainless steel fox tail plug, I still think it’s adorable.

Love Bunny Steel Furry Tail Butt Plug Review

10 out of 10
Price:
£25.00
Materials:
Metal
I was thrilled to be given the opportunity to test out my first ever metal toy: the Love Bunny Steel Furry Tail Butt Plug! I had heard many things about metal for sex toys being akin to glass (which I love!), so hoped it would live up to the hype.
Crystal Delights Crystal Minx Black Fox Tail Butt Plug Review

Crystal Delights Crystal Minx Black Fox Tail Butt Plug Review

10 out of 10
Price:
£69.99
Shop:
SheVibe
Materials:
Glass
I love this butt plug tail. It is an important addition to my exciting BDSM role-play and kinky toys collection and an item which we use often, both in the bedroom and for fun photo shoots and role-play. The Crystal Delights Crystal Minx Black Fox Tail Butt Plug is compatible with any type of lubricant and isn't too large for me. As it is non-porous it can be hygienically cleaned to be shared. It's a fantastic investment and a must for anyone with an interest in the sexual allure of tails.
Crystal Delights Crystal Minx Black Bunny Tail Butt Plug Review

Crystal Delights Crystal Minx Black Bunny Tail Butt Plug Review

10 out of 10
Price:
£69.99
Shop:
SheVibe
Materials:
Glass
The Crystal Delights Crystal Minx Black Bunny Tail Butt Plug has universal, unisex appeal; plus it is latex and phthalates free. It isn't too large to intimidate newbies but will fulfil anal enthusiasts too.