Butt Plug Reviews

Butt Plug Reviews: Find the Best Anal Toys for You

Whether you're an anal play beginner or an experienced user, finding the right butt plug is essential for pleasure and comfort. In my butt plug reviews, I explore different sizes, shapes, and materials to help you choose the perfect one for your needs.

Shop: USA | UK | Europe | Canada | Australia | New Zealand

From beginner-friendly trainer sets to high-tech vibrating options, I test and review a wide variety of plugs so you can make an informed decision.

Choosing the Right Butt Plug: What to Consider

Not all anal toys are the same. Here’s what to think about before you buy:

  • Size Matters – Anal toys often feel larger than expected. Pay attention to the circumference and not just the length.
  • Material & Safety – Choose body-safe, non-porous materials like silicone or glass for hygiene and durability.
  • Vibrating vs Non-Vibrating – Prefer deep, rumbly vibrations or a simple, solid plug? My reviews cover both styles.
  • Special Features – Remote-controlled, rechargeable, weighted, or even connected to a cock ring—there’s a plug for every preference!

Related: My guide to finding the best anal toy for you

Lube Is Essential for Anal Play

Unlike the vagina, the anus doesn’t produce natural lubrication, so a high-quality anal lubricant is a must. I recommend using long-lasting, thicker lubes to ensure a smooth, comfortable experience. Avoid desensitising gels, as they can mask discomfort and increase the risk of injury.

Find Your Perfect Butt Plug

From small, tapered plugs for beginners to advanced anal toys with intense sensations, I’ve reviewed them all. Read my detailed, honest reviews to discover the best butt plug for your desires. Explore now!

Disclaimer: this page contains sponsored reviews & affiliate links

Cal Exotics Booty Call Vibrating Anal Beads Review

Cal Exotics Booty Call Vibrating Anal Beads Review

7 out of 10
Price:
£35.00
Once all of the beads were in I switched the vibrations on, ooooh it felt really good, I love powerful vibrations so I turned it up to speed 3. The vibrations reached all those sensitive nerve endings, which felt delightful. I found it difficult to move the beads due to the length of them, leaving it stationary and with a little clitoral stimulation I had a very intense orgasm.

Aneros Progasm Classic Review

9 out of 10
Price:
£39.99
Brand:
Aneros
Shop:
Aneros
Materials:
Plastic
The Aneros Progasm Classic Prostate Massager is not my first anal sex toy. As a bisexual man I have experimented a lot and my female partner loves experimenting anally with me too. I have tried the Aneros Helix before which is a little smaller and for a beginner you might want to start with the Helix.

MEO Big Johnny Steel Dildo Review

8 out of 10
Price:
£88.00
Brand:
MEO
Shop:
MEO.de
Materials:
Metal
After a little teasing (the Big Johnny certainly lives up to his name, so I wanted to be prepared), I handed Big Johnny over to my hubby - who immediately wished he'd worn gloves, the steel despite being held in our hands, was still on the cold side. Lying on my back we started with the smaller bulb, hubby slowly moved the MEO Big Johnny Steel Dildo over my vulva and clit, the coldness made me jolt and my skin immediately covered with goosebumps sending tingles shooting through my body. The weight pressing down on my clit was also an enjoyable sensation.
Tantus Prostate Play Silicone P-Spot Massager review

Tantus Prostate Play Silicone P-Spot Massager Review

6 out of 10
Price:
£39.99
Brand:
Tantus
Materials:
Silicone
I love the idea of a cock free, hands free orgasm, not least because I’m 'stuck' in chastity at the moment. It’s been more than 100 days since I’ve had an orgasm, and I have at least 20 more to wait, so I was overjoyed that my wife gave me permission to try the prostate massager as long as my chastity device stayed on.
Rocks Off Butt Boy Slim Intense Review

Rocks Off Butt Boy Slim Intense Review

10 out of 10
Price:
£65.99
Rocks Off recently launched the Rocks Off Butt Boy Slim Intense after much planning and carefully listening to feedback from their customers on the design. The result is a powerful perineum massager/butt plug that checks off all the boxes.

MEO Pig Tail Butt Plug Review

7 out of 10
Price:
£44.00
Brand:
MEO
Shop:
MEO.de
Materials:
PVC
Once we finally got chance to get it open we had a lot of fun. Although the butt plug has a very smooth look it did require plenty of lube (water based lubricant only) as the PVC is quite tacky and would just rub and be painful otherwise. The girth of the MEO Pig Tail Butt Plug is great especially if you haven’t had much practice but would be good if there was options of different sizes as it could be a struggle to keep in place as the neck of the plug is not much narrower than the part inserted.

MEO Fox Tail Butt Plug Review

8 out of 10
Price:
£45.00
Brand:
MEO
Shop:
MEO.de
Materials:
Metal
It really doesn't take much to get me into kitten play mode and after putting the MEO Fox Tail Butt Plug in I was right in the head space. I proceeded to prance around showing off my new tail to my owner. I was in kitten heaven! It made my owner happy to see his kitten so happy. He could tell I was by the prancing and general body language, not forgetting the happy mews! No matter how much prancing I did, the tail stayed put. In order to test the tail out properly I thought I better also curl up on my owners' lap for pets. My new tail was going down a treat.
Tom of Finland 5 Speed Silicone Vibrator Review

Tom of Finland 5 Speed Silicone Vibrator Review

7 out of 10
Price:
£50.00
Shop:
SheVibe
Materials:
Silicone
I'd be lying if I said Tom of Finland's gay pornographic art doesn't get me hot under the collar, but my appreciation runs much deeper. I love the conspiratorial glances, the glints of greedy lust and the visible pleasure, however the thing I love most is the self-acceptance evident in all of Tom's men. As someone who has struggled to accept their kinks, I find the lack of shame heartening.
Rocks Off RO-ZEN Pro Review

Rocks Off RO-ZEN Pro Review

8 out of 10
Price:
£49.99
The Rocks Off RO-ZEN Pro is a combined prostate massager and cock ring. The main body is made of soft, flexible body-safe silicone which is comfortable and had no sharp edges to cause discomfort to your oh so delicate parts.

Fun Factory B Balls Anal Toy in Black Review

7 out of 10
Price:
£24.99
Shop:
SheVibe
Materials:
Silicone
Cleaning the Fun Factory B Balls is no big deal, you just wash it thoroughly in the sink, there's no fancy methods needed really. It did make me wonder why they didn't just completely cover the balls in silicone, instead of having the little grey parts showing, as this just creates more nooks and crannies to clean, but whatever.
Sportsheets Please Flared Base Silicone Dildo Review

Sportsheets Please Flared Base Silicone Dildo Review (Lavender Pearl)

9 out of 10
Price:
£23.99
Shop:
SheVibe
Materials:
Silicone
Strap-on play was fantastic fun and we used the Sportsheets Please Flared Base Silicone Dildo as our warm up dildo. What I did enjoy is the fact that I could really go for it on his rear with no fear of hurting him.
Fifty Shades of Grey Driven By Desire Silicone Butt Plug Review

Fifty Shades of Grey Driven By Desire Silicone Butt Plug Review

9 out of 10
I realise that toys like this are very individual as everyone is built differently and it may not be the right size and shape for everyone, but for me the Fifty Shades of Grey Driven By Desire Silicone Butt Plug was in the Goldilocks band and consequently “just right”.

Kinky Tails Pink Pony Tail Glass Butt Plug Review

10 out of 10
Price:
£27.99
Brand:
Bondara
Shop:
Bondara
Materials:
Glass
I have a real obsession with My Little Pony so when my other half mentioned buying a pony tail butt plug I was totally excited by the suggestion. I wanted something pretty and girly and My Little Pony-ish but looking around found that lots of the really pretty tail plugs were very pricey and was reluctant to pay out a lot of money for something we had no experience in.
Rocks Off Wild Boy Prostate Massager Reviews

Rocks Off Wild Boy Prostate Massager Reviews

8 out of 10
Price:
£49.99
I was excited to test drive this bad boy, but perhaps too keen on initial use, as I neglected to get myself appropriately relaxed down below to successfully accommodate it. As with many folk, it takes me a fair bit of prep – liberal application of lube, finger play, and patience – to take a toy much less anything else, comfortably!

Nexus Ace Large Rechargeable Vibrating Butt Plug Review

6 out of 10
Price:
£70.00
This is a good, big butt plug. The vibrations weren't as rumbly and strong as I was anticipating, but they did add a little bit to the experience. I had to warm up a ton to get the Nexus Ace Large Remote Control Butt Plug in, which was nice that a large was really a large. The remote control was a nice extra, you could in theory use it in public, but I wasn't that brave.

Nexus Ridge Rider Prostate Massager Review

8 out of 10
Price:
£55.00
I was really excited to be chosen by Cara Sutra to test and review the Nexus Ridge Rider Prostate Massager. I am a massive fan of prostate play and already own quite a few prostate massagers / toys and was really keen to get my hands on this and give it a go.
B-Vibe Rechargeable Vibrating Rimming Butt Plug Review

B-Vibe Rechargeable Vibrating Rimming Butt Plug Review

7 out of 10
Price:
£109.99
Brand:
B Vibe
Materials:
Silicone
It's a rare day when I spy a sex toy and feel an overwhelming need to own it, touch it, feel it for myself. But that’s exactly what happened when I first saw the B-Vibe Rechargeable Vibrating Rimming Butt Plug online.

Nexus Titus Prostate Massager Review

4 out of 10
Price:
£45.00
The Nexus Titus Prostate Massager (in white for me also comes in black, red and purple) is a "prostate massager with a ribbed shaft for extra sensation, stainless steel roller ball for perineum stimulation and a pebble shaped head for precision pleasure."
Nexus Anal Starter Kit Triple Butt Plug Set March 2016 Pleasure Panel Review

Nexus Anal Starter Kit Review

9 out of 10
Price:
£40.00
When I opened the parcel I was pleasantly surprised by the product packaging of the Nexus Anal Starter Kit as seen in my first photo. It is a quite study and durable cardboard with a plastic window so as to be able to see the product before opening. Another added bonus was a small circle in the lower right corner which contains a sample of the brushed silicone used in the manufacture of the product.

LELO LOKI Vibrating Prostate Massager Review

10 out of 10
Price:
£119.99
Brand:
LELO
Materials:
Silicone
As my fun went on, I continued to play with the LELO LOKI Vibrating Prostate Massager moving it about in various positions which made me writhe and quick till I reached a stage where I was ready to climax. When I did finally climax I found it to be wonderful, and certainly made want to go for a 2nd round just to try and experience the same wonderful sensations again.