Butt Plug Reviews

Butt Plug Reviews: Find the Best Anal Toys for You

Whether you're an anal play beginner or an experienced user, finding the right butt plug is essential for pleasure and comfort. In my butt plug reviews, I explore different sizes, shapes, and materials to help you choose the perfect one for your needs.

Shop: USA | UK | Europe | Canada | Australia | New Zealand

From beginner-friendly trainer sets to high-tech vibrating options, I test and review a wide variety of plugs so you can make an informed decision.

Choosing the Right Butt Plug: What to Consider

Not all anal toys are the same. Here’s what to think about before you buy:

  • Size Matters – Anal toys often feel larger than expected. Pay attention to the circumference and not just the length.
  • Material & Safety – Choose body-safe, non-porous materials like silicone or glass for hygiene and durability.
  • Vibrating vs Non-Vibrating – Prefer deep, rumbly vibrations or a simple, solid plug? My reviews cover both styles.
  • Special Features – Remote-controlled, rechargeable, weighted, or even connected to a cock ring—there’s a plug for every preference!

Related: My guide to finding the best anal toy for you

Lube Is Essential for Anal Play

Unlike the vagina, the anus doesn’t produce natural lubrication, so a high-quality anal lubricant is a must. I recommend using long-lasting, thicker lubes to ensure a smooth, comfortable experience. Avoid desensitising gels, as they can mask discomfort and increase the risk of injury.

Find Your Perfect Butt Plug

From small, tapered plugs for beginners to advanced anal toys with intense sensations, I’ve reviewed them all. Read my detailed, honest reviews to discover the best butt plug for your desires. Explore now!

Disclaimer: this page contains sponsored reviews & affiliate links

Nexus G-Play Plus Trio Rechargeable Unisex Massager Set Review

Nexus G-Play Plus Trio Rechargeable Unisex Massager Set Review

9 out of 10
Price:
£65.00
I was given the opportunity to review this cracking little set, free of charge in exchange for my review here at the Cara Sutra sex blog. Read all about my thoughts on the Nexus G-Play Plus Trio Rechargeable Unisex Massager Set from Nexus Range below…
Nexus G-Stroker Rechargeable Unisex G-Spot Massager Review

Nexus G-Stroker Rechargeable Unisex G-Spot Massager Review

2 out of 10
Price:
£100.00
Both my other half and I enjoy a bit of anal play so when I noticed the Nexus G-Stroker Rechargeable Unisex G-Spot Massager available to review from Cara Sutra I couldn't resist throwing my name in the hat to review it. Many thanks to Cara for selecting me to put this gadget through its paces.
Nexus G-Play Plus Large Rechargeable Vibrating Butt Plug Review

Nexus G-Play Plus Large Rechargeable Vibrating Butt Plug Review (Red)

9 out of 10
Price:
£35.00
After reviewing the Nexus Anal Starter Set during last month's Pleasure Panel round, I was pleased to see more Nexus products up for testing in the latest round. Whilst all of the items looked great, I knew I’d had success with the largest plug from the set so I decided to volunteer for the Nexus G-Play Plus Large Rechargeable Vibrating Butt Plug in Red and see what this toy would feel like with the addition of vibrations.
Nexus Revo Slim Rechargeable Rotating Prostate Massager Review

Nexus Revo Slim Rechargeable Rotating Prostate Massager Review

10 out of 10
Price:
£150.00
I was given the opportunity to review the Nexus Revo Slim Rechargeable Rotating Prostate Massager by Cara Sutra & Nexus Range. Having previous experience with using remote control butt plugs on my submissive I was looking forward to seeing if this one lived up to my high expectations and its considerable price tag.

Titus Silicone Series Remote Control Small Puppy Tail Pro Review | Pleasure Panel

9 out of 10
Price:
£59.99
Brand:
Titus
Materials:
Silicone
I was delighted when I saw the Titus Silicone Series Remote Control Small Puppy Tail Pro available for review as part of the Pleasure Panel as I have recently started puppy play with my female submissive. Already having a collar and knee pads, I was keen to add a tail to her outfit.
Blush Novelties Naughty Candy Hearts Spank Me Butt Plug Review

Blush Novelties Naughty Candy Hearts Spank Me Butt Plug Review

8 out of 10
Price:
£12.95
Shop:
SheVibe
Materials:
Silicone
The pastel yellow of the Blush Novelties Naughty Candy Hearts Spank Me Butt Plug instantly appealed to me simply for not being another of the usual sea of pinks and purples that toy companies seem to insist we all want. Also, 'Spank Me' is one of my favourite phrases to utter during sex. I loved the idea of cheekily slipping the Candy Heart "Spank Me" Butt Plug in and letting a partner find it there nestled between my cheeks, inviting them.
Nexus Revo Slim Rechargeable Rotating Prostate Massager Review

Nexus Revo Slim Rechargeable Rotating Prostate Massager Review

9 out of 10
Price:
£150.00
What a round of toys the community was offered to review this month, with so many offerings from Nexus I really felt like we were being spoiled and I was excited no matter which one of the toys I got to test out.  When I think of Nexus sex toys, I always consider them to be at the premium end of male anal and prostate play toys, so I was really looking forward to testing out the Nexus Revo Slim Rechargeable Rotating Prostate Massager that I had been selected to test out.
Nexus G-Play Plus Medium Rechargeable Vibrating Butt Plug Review

Nexus G-Play Plus Medium Rechargeable Vibrating Butt Plug Review

7 out of 10
Price:
£28.00
I was lucky enough this month to receive two items to review for Cara Sutra's sex blog.  Even better, both items were from Nexus, who I consider to be the front runners in male anal toy offerings.  So, I was quite excited as I waited for the Nexus G-Play Plus Medium Rechargeable Vibrating Butt Plug in Red from Nexus Range to arrive.

Titus Silicone Series Medium Puppy Tail Butt Plug Review | Pleasure Panel

9 out of 10
Price:
£39.99
Brand:
Titus
Materials:
Silicone
This month, I got to indulge in a little puppy play, thanks to Clonezone. This is the Titus Silicone Series Medium Puppy Tail Butt Plug, available now for £39.99.

Loving Joy Furry Fantasy Rainbow Tail Butt Plug Review

7 out of 10
Price:
£24.95
Materials:
Metal
Why just wave a flag for Pride Month when I can wiggle my rainbow-tail-plugged bisexual arse instead? This lovely looking butt plug -which is made of metal and has a faux fur rainbow tail- costs just £24.95. It's part of Loving Joy's Furry Fantasy collection, and like many Loving Joy sex toys it's extremely reasonably priced.

Lovehoney Lifelike Lover 5.5 Inch Pink Realistic Silicone Dildo Review

10 out of 10
Price:
£24.99
The Lovehoney Lifelike Lover 5.5 Inch Pink Realistic Silicone Dildo was perfect. It wasn't intimidating or anything but sure is perfect for beginners - although I am not one of those lol. I love the size, its compact, easy to stash away and can be used on your own, with your partner, on your partner and is harness compatible.

Nexus Anal Starter Butt Plug Kit Review

8 out of 10
Price:
£40.00
With so many different shapes, sizes and styles to choose from, it’s easy to get overwhelmed when picking out sex toys for the first time or choosing from a new category that you haven’t explored before. That’s why I find products like the Nexus Anal Starter Butt Plug Kit really helpful to recommend to people who haven’t encountered such toys before. This kit is made up of three different plug sizes and these come in small, medium and large.

Lovehoney Lifelike Lover 8 Inch Purple Realistic Silicone Dildo With Balls Review

10 out of 10
Price:
£32.99
With Lovehoney recently launching their "Lifelike Lover Collection" of dildos featuring 32 different shapes, sizes and styles, I was delighted to be chosen in the May Pleasure Panel round to try out the Lovehoney Lifelike Lover 8 Inch Purple Realistic Silicone Dildo With Balls.
Doc Johnson Booty Bling Jewelled Silicone Butt Plug Review

Doc Johnson Booty Bling Jewelled Silicone Butt Plug Review

5 out of 10
Price:
£15.95
Due to its small size, I found the Doc Johnson Booty Bling Jewelled Silicone Butt Plug incredibly easy to insert. The stem on the plug is quite long considering its size giving it a good usable length and the flexibility of the silicone makes the very pretty Doc Johnson Booty Bling Jewelled Silicone Butt Plug very comfortable to wear whether for a few minutes or the whole day and night! When it says wearable, it really does mean it.
Aneros Helix Trident Prostate Massager Review

Aneros Helix Trident Review

7 out of 10
Price:
£40.00
Brand:
Aneros
Shop:
Aneros
Materials:
Plastic
The Aneros Helix Trident Prostate Massager arrives in a nicely designed box with various embossed designs featuring the Helix.  After popping open the top the sleek insert holding the massageral is very thoughtfully put together, magnets hold the flaps together and once opened reveal a user guide and the g-spot stimulator encased in its own plastic bed.  All very nice to look at!

Lovehoney UPRIZE Self-Erecting Bionic Dildo & Strap-On Harness Review

9 out of 10
Price:
£129.99
Nowadays it's extremely rare that I see a sex toy I'm genuinely excited about, but back when I first saw online mentions of the Lovehoney UPRIZE range I knew I needed one of these self-erecting dildos in my life. Testament to this was my immediate and enthusiastic yes please response when Lovehoney offered me their Lovehoney UPRIZE Self-Erecting Bionic Dildo Vibrator (8 inches, in Black) to review. Not only that, Lovehoney also kindly sent me the Lovehoney UPRIZE Strap-On Harness too.
Rocks Off Black Petite Sensations Teazer Vibrating Butt Plug Review

Rocks Off Black Petite Sensations Teazer Vibrating Butt Plug Review

7 out of 10
Price:
£16.99
...the Rocks Off Black Petite Sensations Teazer Vibrating Butt Plug is the perfect size to explore penetration of any kind. Whether you’ve got trouble with vaginal penetration or want to cautiously explore anal play, the Teazer Butt Plug gently eases you into things the way a single finger would. And it has a feature fingers don’t have: it vibrates.

Lovehoney Wowzer Double Cock Ring and Vibrating Butt Plug Review

9 out of 10
Price:
£26.99
I received this Lovehoney Wowzer Double Cock Ring and Vibrating Butt Plug from Lovehoney recently and was really excited about trying it. I built up the anticipation by sharing ideas and thoughts between myself and the submissive who I had in mind for this. It was worth the wait.
Rocks Off O Boy 7 Speed Prostate Massager Review

Rocks Off O Boy 7 Speed Prostate Massager Review

3 out of 10
Price:
£39.95
The Rocks Off O Boy 7 Speed Prostate Massager is a silicone toy so water based lube is the way to go. The toy itself has a slight matte texture which is good for holding lube on the toy during use. It is also battery operated. You will need to open the toy by twisting the vibe to remove the little piece of paper that prevents the toy from activating in the package.
Crystal Delights 5 Color Faux Pony Tail Butt Plug Review

Crystal Delights 5 Color Faux Pony Tail Butt Plug Review

10 out of 10
Price:
£90.00
Shop:
SheVibe
Materials:
Glass
Crystal Delights are a well-known US based brand specialising in the most beautiful tail plugs I’ve ever seen. As well as their famous tails Crystal Delights make stunning princess plugs with jewels of all assorted colours. They’re the kind of sex toy you don’t want to hide.